Pastel vs. Oil Pet Portraits: Which Is Right for Your Pet?

How the two mediums compare on cost, framing, and durability, and how to choose.

I paint custom pet portraits in both pastel and oil from my studio in Burlington, Vermont. The two mediums look different and are cared for differently. Their total finished costs often end up very similar, just balanced differently between the artwork and the framing. Here’s what to know before you choose.

What Are the Differences Between Oil and Pastel Portraits?

Custom oil pet portrait by Kimberly Provost, varnished and framed without glass

Oil Paintings

Traditional oil paintings are varnished once dry and framed open, without glass so you can see the brushwork directly. The varnish protects the portrait from dust and debris.

Custom pastel pet portrait framed behind museum glass with archival mat — Kimberly Provost, Burlington VT

Pastel Paintings

Pastel paintings are more delicate and must be framed behind glass with an archival mat or hidden spacers to keep the pigment from touching the glass. Once a painting is framed behind glass, it will last generations and maintain its vibrancy and beauty. I highly recommend having your portraits professionally framed. I also recommend using museum glass which is very clear and low glare and keeps the beauty of the portrait visible from all angles.

How Do the Costs of Pastel and Oil Portraits Compare?

While the pricing is structured differently, the overall investment often evens out. Oil paintings cost more to create due to materials and extended studio drying times, but they are inexpensive to frame since they don't require glass. Pastels cost less to paint, though they require specialized framing under glass with spacers or mats to protect the surface.

Pastel vs. Oil at a Glance
Feature Oil Portrait Pastel Portrait
Cost to paint Higher (materials and extended studio drying times) Lower
Cost to frame Lower (no glass required) Higher (glass plus mat or spacers)
Finish Varnished once dry Delicate pigment, protected behind glass
Framing style Framed open, so brushwork and texture are visible Framed behind glass with an archival mat or hidden spacers
Overall investment Often very similar Often very similar

Do You Offer Framing?

While I do not personally frame the portraits, I collaborate with a professional frame shop located in Vermont who handles all framing for my personal projects. If you would like to include professional framing, I am happy to coordinate this service for you.

Framing options for oil or pastel pet portraits

Ready to Commission a Portrait?

Not sure which medium suits your pet? Tell me about them and we'll figure it out together.

For pricing and size options, see more information here.

Lucah - pet portrait painted with oil paints

Lucah - pet portrait painted with oil paints